IKORIA – In a world of monsters, Jeskai’s the limit : Companion Rulings

Hello Oathbreakers! The new set brings some awesome and powerful cards and mechanics to the world of Magic. Today we'd like to talk about some of these cards and more specifically the mechanic of Companion. Wizards realized the implications of this mechanic in formats outside of their control and gave the Commander rules committee advance notice. We however, did not receive this advance notice. We discovered these cards at the same time you did and called a meeting to discuss.

Call the Gatewatch - Illustrated by Yefim Kligerman
Call the Gatewatch - Illustrated by Yefim Kligerman

The mechanic of Companion presents multiple questions, related to the multiple parts of the mechanic:

 

A Companion is cast from outside the game; Does Oathbreaker allow this?

Under the existing rules, Oathbreaker has no sideboard and abilities which refer to outside the game do not function. While Commander also has the same rules affecting this, we don't believe accommodating this mechanic is the correct course of action. It would bring into question things like burning wish [] that we have already decided are not in the best interest of the format as having an explicit deck size that all players must work with is one of the core parts of the Oathbreaker format. Adding a sideboard or wishboard of any variation breaks from that symmetry of what players bring to the table and allows for 'silver bullets' to be safely accessible to the decks that can access them without drawing them at an inopportune time.

 

Companion cards require a deck building condition to be met; How difficult is it to meet these requirements within the existing requirements of Oathbreaker?

The companion requirements vary greatly between free and impossible to achieve. Lutri, the Spellchaser [] (U/R) has a restriction already in place by the singleton nature of the format. Kaheera, the Orphanguard [] (W/G) and Zirda, the Dawnmaker [] (W/R) are fairly easy to satisfy as they only have restrictions on a subset of the deck. (R/G), Keruga, the macrosage [] (U/G), Obosh, the preypiercer [] (R/B), Gyruda, doom of depths [] (U/B) have restrictions that are difficult to achieve without creating a significant disadvantage. Lurrus of the dream-den [] (W/B) and Umori, the collector [] (B/G) are (currently) impossible due to existing restrictions within Oathbreaker deckbuilding. The only unknown is the W/U companion, but with the currently revealed cards we can already see a large imbalance on which color combinations benefit from this mechanic within the context of Oathbreaker.

 

The cards with Companion are creatures with abilities; How impactful are these other abilities?

The above mentioned companion creatures are the only ones currently available to us, and while they all have cool and exciting abilities beyond their namesake mechanic, none are expected to warp the format from within the deck.

The takeaway:

Companion will not function in Oathbreaker. The rules do not allow it, the companions being released would be varied between free to impossible, and the cards are both fun and unique - without being companions. Consequently, no emergency-pre-bans are necessary and we look forward to all of the cool new potential Ikoria brings to Oathbreaker.

 

We'll be back with our originally scheduled Banned List announcement April 24th, 2020.

Home Forums IKORIA – In a world of monsters, Jeskai’s the limit : Companion Rulings

This topic contains 2 replies, has 3 voices, and was last updated by  riafasha 1 week, 2 days ago.

  • Author
    Posts
  • #2783

    MagicManRandySavage
    Community Member

    Hello Oathbreakers! The new set brings some awesome and powerful cards and mechanics to the world of Magic. Today we’d like to talk about some of thes
    [See the full post at: IKORIA – In a world of monsters, Jeskai’s the limit : Companion Rulings]

  • #2786

    EitanR
    Community Member

    I am happy and relieved that this new companion mechanic didn’t trigger automatic bans. Some of the cards seem like they’ll be a lot of fun to use even without the companion mechanic, just as regular part of the deck.

  • #3168

    riafasha
    Community Member

    Hai thankyou for information

    I’am Riafasha from Indonesia

Login so you can join the discussion! Login Register